We are moving our forum in GitHub Discussions. For questions about Phalcon v3/v4 you can visit here and for Phalcon v5 here.

Models, business logic

Hi all!

I started using Phalcon and have some confusion with models... Where should I keep my business logic? I don't want fat controllers;) As for me is habitually to have models as Table and Row (like Zend 1: Zend_Db_Table and Zend_Db_Table_Row)

Maybe there are any best practices?

Put business logic in events like beforeSave, afterSave? I think it's not a silver bullet.


It is entirely up to you where you put your business logic. The discussion about whether to have fat controllers or fat models is a long one and you will see that both sides are both right and wrong at the same time.

I have always kept my controllers thin and used more of a fat model approach. You can do the same but it is your choice to do so.

What I usually do is ensure for starters that all my models are properly defined with getters and setters. Although using a getter/setter is "slower" than using a public variable, much of my validations and logic does happen in my getters/setters so I prefer that over a direct access (to the public variable) approach.

beforeSave/afterSave are also good places to put logic in. If possible you can pass some of the processing to your database using triggers which can help tremendously in terms of performance. For instance if you want to update fields such as created_date and updated_date in your table, you can use triggers instead of code. (see here: https://www.niden.net/2013/09/let-rdbms-do-more-than-just-store-data.html)

You don't necessarily need to have a model Table and Row. You can do everything with a base model and the ones that extend it. It is just a different way of coding that's all.

Hey, Business logic is your application logic. Code that creates/manipulates your data. In terms of rails, you'll often run into a discussion of where business logic belongs. Skinny controllers/fat models, etc. Most of that, use the marketing aspect. Explainer videos, Cartoons, Character Animation, Commercials, TV spots that can work well for your business. In this case, check this website - https://darvideo.tv/cartoon-explainers/